The thing the experts don't tell you about newborns
I always feel badly for a new mom when I see her struggling to get the little one on a schedule. There are so many books (and friends, and grandmothers, and meddling perfect strangers) out there claiming that schedules are the answer to preventing sleep, feeding, discipline, and basically all other possible problems.
The thing I generally find lacking in the scheduling philosophy is a recognition that a newborn is
a) a newborn, and
b) an individual human being.
I hear a lot of astonishment from the new mom set that the baby sometimes wants to eat every hour all afternoon. Or that their first nap falls an hour after waking up in the morning. Or that if the parents don't pay attention to the baby's preferred schedule and the baby misses a nap, the baby will promptly come unhinged.
I know, I was astonished too, because I read the same books as everyone else. And I expected that I would be molding my baby like a little pink lump of play dough. What I actually experienced was that the baby shaped me. It was like being in a really loud Skinner box. She would freak and I would try stuff until something changed and allowed her to relax, or poop, or sleep, or eat, or whatever she was needing. And pretty soon, I got better at figuring out the puzzle.
It makes me sad to see new moms staggering along under a load of self-or-other imposed restrictions on their baby care. Some won't pick the baby up. Some won't feed the baby until it's "time", and then cut off the feed after a small, fixed number of minutes so the baby will feed efficiently during feedings and not at all in between. Some feel it teaches self-soothing skills to let the baby cry to sleep from a very young age. And so on.
I'm sure some babies are naturally easy to schedule, or tend to be self-soothers, and then this all works out fine. But many babies are, well, babies, and will resist with all their tiny might. So my thought is that the best course is to first go with the baby's schedule and figure out who this little person is that you're dealing with, and later on introduce your own preferences into the mix. The idea that we can tell a newborn when to be hungry seems as silly to me as the idea that we can tell them when to pee. We cannot ultimately control who our kids are, and the sooner we get used to that idea, the better.
